Skip to content

Explainer, read 16 November 2026

Red team legal authorization: the letter and the law

Open the scoping sheetSee the frameworks table

What authorization does a red team test need?

It needs a signed document from senior management that commissions and sanctions the test. The Singapore guidelines call it a letter of engagement and say it should briefly describe the intent of the test, the extent of the testers' involvement and how to authenticate them during a possible investigation.

NIST SP 800-115 expects the test team lead and the organization's senior management to sign the rules of engagement, and for physical testing it expects a form with signatures and contacts that testers can show to law enforcement or security staff.

What does the letter protect against?

It protects testers who are stopped mid-test. If staff apprehend a tester, the letter and the named contact prove the test is sanctioned. NIST says guards should be made aware of how to verify tester activity, for example through a point of contact or documentation.

The letter does not replace the scope. Activity outside the agreed scope is not covered by the permission given for the scoped test.

Which laws should counsel review?

TIBER-EU lists activities that need legal review: gathering open-source intelligence on the entity, its suppliers, employees and customers; gathering data from other intelligence sources and the dark web; gathering account and password data from employees and providers; placing people into the entity under various guises; and using ruses by email, telephone and in person.

The framework says entities should carry out a thorough legal analysis with appropriate legal expertise, and that contractual consent with the full agreement of the entity mitigates many concerns. All parties are prohibited from illegal and unethical actions.

What about third parties such as cloud and managed service providers?

They may need to agree or take part. CBEST says third parties may need to be part of the control group where important systems underpinning a service are outsourced. Under DORA, the financial entity must take the measures to ensure ICT third-party providers in scope take part and keeps full responsibility.

The EU rules also let the entity and a provider agree in writing for the provider to contract an external tester directly, where participation could affect the provider's other customers.

What contract terms matter?

Liability, insurance, confidentiality and data. The Singapore guidelines say the provider should be kept legally liable through the scope of work, sign a confidentiality agreement, and hold insurance and indemnity, and that mutual damages and the provider's financial capacity deserve attention. TIBER-EU requires professional indemnity cover that includes misconduct and negligence.

Sources

  1. Association of Banks in Singapore, Red Team: Adversarial Attack Simulation Exercise Guidelines, September 2024, read 16 November 2026
  2. NIST SP 800-115, Technical Guide to Information Security Testing and Assessment, September 2008, read 16 November 2026
  3. European Central Bank, TIBER-EU Framework, January 2025, read 16 November 2026
  4. Bank of England, CBEST Implementation Guide, 2024 edition, read 16 November 2026
  5. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 (DORA), read 16 November 2026
  6. European Central Bank, TIBER-EU Guidance for Service Provider Procurement, 2025, read 16 November 2026

Last reviewed 16 November 2026.